Stocks Heard a Dove. The Bond Market Didn’t.

stock-heard-dove

On Wednesday afternoon the Federal Reserve held interest rates steady for a fifth consecutive meeting, and stocks buckled: the Dow fell 1,153 points, its worst day since April of last year. That evening Microsoft reported blowout earnings, and on Thursday its shares added roughly $450 billion in market value — the largest single-day gain any company has ever recorded. By Friday's close the S&P 500 had recovered everything it lost on Fed day and more, finishing the week higher at 7,489.72, only about a percent and a half below the record it set in early June. Beneath the rebound, though, the week's most important number moved the other way: the yield on the thirty-year Treasury climbed to 5.27%, a level last seen in 2007, and the ten-year reached 4.75%, its high for the year. This is not two markets disagreeing about the facts. Both listened to the same press conference — a central bank that talks about 2% inflation and, for the fifth meeting running, declined to act on it. Stocks flinched, then — with Microsoft's help — heard a dove, and to stocks a patient Fed is a gift: easy money, strong earnings, buy. The bond market heard a debtor: a government borrowing close to $2 trillion a year, whose central bank will not defend its inflation target, must pay its longest lenders more — and so long-term yields rose even as stocks rallied. Same message; the argument is over what it costs. And because every valuation in the stock market ultimately rests on the rate the bond market sets, only one of these tapes can be right for long. We think it is the bond market's, and explaining why is the purpose of this letter.
s&p-500

See more: Fed Watch: Is It a Matter of When, Not If?

It has been nearly two months since our June 8 update, and the news came quickly. At his first meeting as Chair in mid-June, Kevin Warsh presided over a remarkable shift: the Fed's published projections flipped from cutting rates to raising them, with nine of eighteen officials penciling in at least one increase this year and the committee lifting its own 2026 inflation forecast to 3.6%. The ceasefire signed with Iran in mid-June collapsed within three weeks, and oil traveled accordingly — Brent from above $110 in the spring to the low $70s at the start of July and back to the high $80s by Friday, with weekend reports of renewed de-escalation talks poised to swing it yet again. That round trip flattered June's inflation report: consumer prices fell 0.4% in the month, the largest one-month decline since April 2020, pulling the annual rate down to 3.5%, with core inflation at 2.6%. Second-quarter growth arrived at a modest-looking 1.5%. Then came Wednesday: another hold, but with three of the twelve voting members formally dissenting because they wanted to raise rates — the most dissent any new Fed chairman has faced this early in his tenure since 1970. Interest-rate futures now lean toward at least one hike before year-end.

10-30yr-treas-yields