Did America Just Become a Nation of Luddites?



Something strange has been happening in America lately. The Wall Street Journal says this is the summer when the U.S. became “a nation of Luddites.” The Economist calls it “the Summer of Ludd.”

Luddites, in case you’re unfamiliar, are historically what we’ve called people who stand in the way of progress and innovation, who want to turn the clock back to a “better time.”

The word comes to us from 18th-century England, near the start of the Industrial Revolution. Followers of Ned Ludd, a fictional weaving apprentice, destroyed textile machinery, mills and factories to protest the advancement of automation.

See more: Midterm Year Pullbacks Have Been Followed by Double-Digit Gains

The violence didn’t stop anything. Parliament made machine-breaking a capital crime. Ringleaders were hanged or shipped off to Australia. Not a single job was saved. As the Economist put it, the Luddites survive in our memory more for their theatricality than for their economic relevance.

I think of that when I read about the growing backlash to data centers.

Why Young People Are Turning Against the AI Buildout

Public perception of data centers right now is not the best, to put it mildly. The Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania ran a survey this summer and found that 61% of American adults oppose new data center construction in their area. That’s 12 points up from the spring. Annenberg says it’s the largest shift they’ve measured on any question about artificial intelligence (AI).