
Consider the comfort contained in a familiar sentence: “I have a diversified portfolio.” Most investors today believe they are diversified. The portfolio feels like a warm blanket stitched together from many different asset classes. But a warm blanket is not the same thing as armor.
It is what I call the diversification delusion.
Look at the market today, as we sit here in the mid-2020s. The surface language is diversification, but the underlying structure is concentration. Technology, and now artificial intelligence, has become not merely a sector but a gravitational field.
Consider what this could mean for a portfolio. An investor owns technology stocks for growth, corporate bonds for income, private credit for an alternative return stream, and real estate and industrial metals for diversification. That is five allocations with five different labels for ostensibly different asset classes. Yet part of each allocation may depend on the continuation of the same investment boom. We can diversify the claims while concentrating the assumptions behind them.
The Elegant Theory
Harry Markowitz’s insight was beautiful: to understand the risk of a portfolio, it is not enough to understand the investments inside it. One also needs to understand their relationships.
The beauty of the theory is that it is both mathematical and intuitive. As my grandma used to say: “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket.” Markowitz gave us a way to ask a more precise question: how differently will the baskets behave? The difficulty begins when we move from the equation to the world.
The Messy Reality
The danger is not in Markowitz’s mathematics. It is in mistaking an estimate for a dependable feature of the world.
Correlation is not engraved on a security. It is a measured relationship between returns over a particular period. BIS researchers documented a shift in U.S. stock–government-bond correlations from negative to positive in mid-2021. In 2022, investors who thought they were diversified across stocks, bonds, and alternatives watched nearly everything fall together. The assets were different, but the gravity was the same.
This is why I hesitate when someone tells me that two assets are uncorrelated. Over what period? Under which conditions? And what might make their owners sell both?
In calm periods, markets can look like independent actors. In a liquidity panic, many begin to behave like members of the same frightened crowd.
See more: Where to Seek Diversification From the AI Investment Theme
Beyond Diversification: A Different Approach to Risk
Outside investing, we are quite comfortable separating a decision to own something from a decision to bear all the risks of owning it. A family can choose a home because it suits their lives without concluding that they should also bear the full financial consequences of a fire. They do not solve that problem by purchasing several more houses in different neighborhoods. They buy insurance.
This was part of what drew me to derivatives early in my career. Working on a trading desk, I came to appreciate that owning an investment did not have to be an indivisible decision. The upside, the downside, the timing of payments, and the financing could be examined separately.
An investment selected for its historical correlation may or may not offset the next loss. An appropriately structured option has a contractual payoff tied to a defined event or outcome. Its usefulness depends on the terms, the period, and how closely it matches the exposure being protected, and not simply on whether a relationship observed in the past happens to persist.
I do not see this as a choice between diversification and risk transfer. They address different parts of the problem and can be used together. The mistake is assuming that the first exercise has necessarily completed the second.
When I think back to the events of 1995, the memory that stays with me is the reassurance people seemed to draw from one another’s certainty. It is an uncomfortable memory because there is no reason to believe that familiarity with markets makes us immune to the same habit. A portfolio assembled according to widely accepted practice can feel well protected before we have examined what that protection consists of.
That is what I mean by the diversification delusion.
My plea is not that everyone should choose concentration, but that we be honest about how concentrated we may already be. We are better served by acknowledging that concentration and managing it deliberately than by taking comfort in diversification we may not actually have.
But acknowledging concentration does not mean resigning ourselves to its consequences. It means staying curious about the gap between what we own and the protection we assume it provides—and embracing the tools now available to decide which risks to retain, reshape, or transfer. Some concentration may be unavoidable. Accepting all the risks that come with it need not be.
This is an abridged version of “The Diversification Delusion.” The full essay, including the hidden connections between asset classes, the incentives that push portfolios toward the same holdings, and the case for concentration, is available at https://www.vestfin.com/field-notes/posts/the-diversification-delusion/
A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: Discover something new! Click here to register for our upcoming webcasts.
© Vest Financial
More Separately Managed Accounts Topics >